banner-image
banner-image
banner-image
banner-image
First & Main Melancholy Mel Dog Plush 14" Get Well Stuffed Animal Toy cast loose

First & Main Melancholy Mel Dog Plush 14" Get Well Stuffed Animal Toy cast loose

$6.46$3.23

Big Teddy Bear with Bow Tie, Large Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal for Kids

Big Teddy Bear with Bow Tie, Large Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal for Kids

$89.34$44.67

Big Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Giant Teddy Bear Plush with Red Ribbon Bow Tan

Big Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Giant Teddy Bear Plush with Red Ribbon Bow Tan

$50.58$25.29

First & Main Menagerie Collection Itty Bitty Kitties Calico Kitten Plush Toy

First & Main Menagerie Collection Itty Bitty Kitties Calico Kitten Plush Toy

$34.65$17.32

Plush First and Main Christmas Snowman Snow Fairy Ivory Believe Star New

Plush First and Main Christmas Snowman Snow Fairy Ivory Believe Star New

$10.38$5.19

First & Main Dean Brown Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Toy No. 1796KG 14"

First & Main Dean Brown Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Toy No. 1796KG 14"

$9.95$4.97

First & Main Prayer Bear Pink White Plush Soft Toy 11" Stuffed Teddy PJs

First & Main Prayer Bear Pink White Plush Soft Toy 11" Stuffed Teddy PJs

$16.95$8.47

First And Main Bailey Bear Plush Gal Pals Stuffed Animal Toy Blue Teddy 7" 2017

First And Main Bailey Bear Plush Gal Pals Stuffed Animal Toy Blue Teddy 7" 2017

$12.00$6.00

First & Main Yellow Gold Stuffed Animal Teddy Bear 7" Plush Toy

First & Main Yellow Gold Stuffed Animal Teddy Bear 7" Plush Toy

$11.04$5.52

First and Main Plush Wuffles Chihuahua Dog Rare Glitter Eyes

First and Main Plush Wuffles Chihuahua Dog Rare Glitter Eyes

$11.99$6.00

Double Dutch Plush Teddy Bear 2015 Stuffed Animal Toy Swirl Fur 15"

Double Dutch Plush Teddy Bear 2015 Stuffed Animal Toy Swirl Fur 15"

$2.74$1.37

Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal, 20 inch Brown Stuffed Teddy Bear Plush Toy, Soft

Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal, 20 inch Brown Stuffed Teddy Bear Plush Toy, Soft

$30.86$15.43

First And Main Teddy Bear 11” Thornton, Curly Lt. Brown ,Faux Leather Nose, EUC

First And Main Teddy Bear 11” Thornton, Curly Lt. Brown ,Faux Leather Nose, EUC

$4.90$2.45

Set Of 2 First & Main Rainbow Bear Green & Orange 6” Plush Stuffed Animal

Set Of 2 First & Main Rainbow Bear Green & Orange 6” Plush Stuffed Animal

$12.00$6.00

First & Main Lion Baby Yellow Plush Stuffed Toy Terry Fleece Textured 14 Inch

First & Main Lion Baby Yellow Plush Stuffed Toy Terry Fleece Textured 14 Inch

$27.99$13.99

First and Main Orange Teddy Bear Rainbow Bears Plush Toy Stuffed Animal 6.5"

First and Main Orange Teddy Bear Rainbow Bears Plush Toy Stuffed Animal 6.5"

$9.86$4.93

Valentine's Day Monkey Stuffed Animal 12 Inch Plush Monkey with Heart Cuddly

Valentine's Day Monkey Stuffed Animal 12 Inch Plush Monkey with Heart Cuddly

$28.69$14.35

First & Main 10" White Teddy Bear w/ Green Bow NO TAGS

First & Main 10" White Teddy Bear w/ Green Bow NO TAGS

$7.55$3.77

First Main Bear Plush Black Dimple 15" Beige Rubber Claws Vintage

First Main Bear Plush Black Dimple 15" Beige Rubber Claws Vintage

$21.03$10.52

First & Main Scraggles the Teddy Bear Brown 11" Stuffed Animal Plush Item 1874

First & Main Scraggles the Teddy Bear Brown 11" Stuffed Animal Plush Item 1874

$8.50$4.25

First & Main Jingles Plush with sounds

First & Main Jingles Plush with sounds

$8.10$4.05

Frog Prince & Frog Princess Plush His/Her Lovey 9.5” Frog Couple First Main Pair

Frog Prince & Frog Princess Plush His/Her Lovey 9.5” Frog Couple First Main Pair

$17.37$8.69

13.5inch Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal, Soft Cuddly Stuffed Plush Bear, Gifts Pink

13.5inch Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal, Soft Cuddly Stuffed Plush Bear, Gifts Pink

$20.25$10.13

First & Main Wuffles Yorkie Puppy Dog Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Pink Collar 3634

First & Main Wuffles Yorkie Puppy Dog Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Pink Collar 3634

$8.56$4.28

First Main Angel Bear Plush 11" 1304 Wing Sitting Guardian Toy Girl Women Pink

First Main Angel Bear Plush 11" 1304 Wing Sitting Guardian Toy Girl Women Pink

$14.99$7.50

First and Main Teddy Bear Dena White Plush Lovey Toy 1786 14"

First and Main Teddy Bear Dena White Plush Lovey Toy 1786 14"

$12.00$6.00

First & Main Lil Nubby 8" Baby Elephant Pastel #2163 Stuffed Rattle Toy Plush

First & Main Lil Nubby 8" Baby Elephant Pastel #2163 Stuffed Rattle Toy Plush

$11.44$5.72

First & Main Scraggles- KOHAIR #1864 Teddy Bear With Blue Bow Tie

First & Main Scraggles- KOHAIR #1864 Teddy Bear With Blue Bow Tie

$15.99$8.00

First Main Sweet Dreamer Sleeping Bear Twas Night Before Christmas Lovey Toy X

First Main Sweet Dreamer Sleeping Bear Twas Night Before Christmas Lovey Toy X

$16.99$8.49

Big Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Big Teddy Bear Mama with Baby Giant Teddy Pink

Big Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Big Teddy Bear Mama with Baby Giant Teddy Pink

$55.32$27.66

First & Main Tumbles Brown Bear Plush 7 Inch 1124 Stuffed Animal Toy

First & Main Tumbles Brown Bear Plush 7 Inch 1124 Stuffed Animal Toy

$23.35$11.68

DOJOZ Crystal Teddy Bear Valentines Day Sweet Gifts Figurine Red Heart White

DOJOZ Crystal Teddy Bear Valentines Day Sweet Gifts Figurine Red Heart White

$131.62$65.81

First & Main Sweet Owlz Plush Pink Stuffed Animal Toy Bird Soft & Cuddly 9"

First & Main Sweet Owlz Plush Pink Stuffed Animal Toy Bird Soft & Cuddly 9"

$11.98$5.99

First & Main Plush Stuffed Animal Frog Thad Polz 11" Chime Rattle #5274 B15

First & Main Plush Stuffed Animal Frog Thad Polz 11" Chime Rattle #5274 B15

$12.05$6.03

First & Main Brown Bear 1797 Dean Plush 20 In Stuffed Green Blue Silver Ribbon

First & Main Brown Bear 1797 Dean Plush 20 In Stuffed Green Blue Silver Ribbon

$11.11$5.55

First & Main Hang A Round Horse Long Hair Joined hands feet Plush with Tags 10"

First & Main Hang A Round Horse Long Hair Joined hands feet Plush with Tags 10"

$8.99$4.50

First & Main Reindeer Named Jingles Plush 8" (See Description)

First & Main Reindeer Named Jingles Plush 8" (See Description)

$12.00$6.00

First & Main Red Tender Teddy Plush Bear Stuffed Toy

First & Main Red Tender Teddy Plush Bear Stuffed Toy

$18.29$9.14

First & Main Plush Lot of 3: Brown Guardian Angel, White Baby Angel, Santa Bear

First & Main Plush Lot of 3: Brown Guardian Angel, White Baby Angel, Santa Bear

$19.99$9.99

First & Main 13" Recuperate Kate Teddy Bear w Pink Robe Slippers & Kitty 56

First & Main 13" Recuperate Kate Teddy Bear w Pink Robe Slippers & Kitty 56

$16.99$8.49

First & Main Plush Stuffed Betty Cow Brown And White Tender Friends Plaid Heart

First & Main Plush Stuffed Betty Cow Brown And White Tender Friends Plaid Heart

$11.97$5.99

Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Cute Teddy Bear Plush Toy 11.8" for red teddy bear

Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Cute Teddy Bear Plush Toy 11.8" for red teddy bear

$18.89$9.45

First and Main Coconut No. 1424 Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Plush Baby Shower Gift

First and Main Coconut No. 1424 Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Plush Baby Shower Gift

$8.00$4.00

First & Main Foxy Lady Plush Fox With Glasses Boa Sequined Dress Valentines Day

First & Main Foxy Lady Plush Fox With Glasses Boa Sequined Dress Valentines Day

$11.18$5.59

First Main Bear Plush 10 Inch Minky 2001 Argosy Casino Hotel Co Stuffed Animal

First Main Bear Plush 10 Inch Minky 2001 Argosy Casino Hotel Co Stuffed Animal

$19.76$9.88

Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Cute Teddy Bears Plush Toy 11.8 inch for blue bear

Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Cute Teddy Bears Plush Toy 11.8 inch for blue bear

$20.50$10.25

First and Main Baby Stork Bird Special Delivery Beanbag Plush Rattle

First and Main Baby Stork Bird Special Delivery Beanbag Plush Rattle

$19.95$9.97

St. Jude Bear First & Main Teddy Bear Plush 11" Tan Brown Green Bow Stuffed

St. Jude Bear First & Main Teddy Bear Plush 11" Tan Brown Green Bow Stuffed

$12.00$6.00

First & Main Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Yellow Bow Tie Gift Toy 6 Inch

First & Main Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Yellow Bow Tie Gift Toy 6 Inch

$5.00$2.50

Vintage First & Main Tucker Teddy Bear 14" Brown Red Ribbon Bow Plush 

Vintage First & Main Tucker Teddy Bear 14" Brown Red Ribbon Bow Plush 

$11.99$6.00

Snuggly Coco Bear Stuffed Animal - Comforting Companion - Imaginative Play -

Snuggly Coco Bear Stuffed Animal - Comforting Companion - Imaginative Play -

$24.93$12.46

Floppy Bow Tie Red

Floppy Bow Tie Red

$25.88$12.94

Plush Frog Froggle Woggle First & Main 12" Sitting Green Rattle Noise Stuffed

Plush Frog Froggle Woggle First & Main 12" Sitting Green Rattle Noise Stuffed

$14.40$7.20

First Main Pink Bear Plush 9 Inch Stuffed Animal Toy

First Main Pink Bear Plush 9 Inch Stuffed Animal Toy

$13.45$6.72

First & Main Plush Brown Monty Monkey With Tail Clasping Hands 13” Soft NWT

First & Main Plush Brown Monty Monkey With Tail Clasping Hands 13” Soft NWT

$8.99$4.50

Sorbet Teddy Bear Easter Pastel Rainbow Multi Colors Lace Feet Plush Animal Toy

Sorbet Teddy Bear Easter Pastel Rainbow Multi Colors Lace Feet Plush Animal Toy

$19.99$9.99

First & Main Plush Teddy Bear Edgar B Evergreen Christmas Red Hat and Vest 12"

First & Main Plush Teddy Bear Edgar B Evergreen Christmas Red Hat and Vest 12"

$17.62$8.81

First & Main Elliott #1885 Teddy Bear 13” Brown Plush Stuffed Animal Toy W/Tags

First & Main Elliott #1885 Teddy Bear 13” Brown Plush Stuffed Animal Toy W/Tags

$10.80$5.40

First and Main Colorful Teddy Bear plush Stuffed Animal Rainbow Sherbet HTF

First and Main Colorful Teddy Bear plush Stuffed Animal Rainbow Sherbet HTF

$29.99$14.99

First Main Cuddle Me Cody Bear Plush White Red Hearts 9 Inch V1574 Stuffed

First Main Cuddle Me Cody Bear Plush White Red Hearts 9 Inch V1574 Stuffed

$11.66$5.83

Green Teddy Bear Stuffed Animals 13.4" Soft Cuddly Stuffed Plush Teddy Green S

Green Teddy Bear Stuffed Animals 13.4" Soft Cuddly Stuffed Plush Teddy Green S

$19.12$9.56

First & Main Sherbet Babies Plush Teddy Bear 1625 Green 8" Sitting Bow Tie

First & Main Sherbet Babies Plush Teddy Bear 1625 Green 8" Sitting Bow Tie

$12.00$6.00

First & Main Light Blue Puppy Dog Plush Rattle Toy Ribbon Bow Sewn Eyes 3384 8"

First & Main Light Blue Puppy Dog Plush Rattle Toy Ribbon Bow Sewn Eyes 3384 8"

$14.24$7.12

First And Main Nubby Floppy Ear Plush Dog with Rattle Baby Toy

First And Main Nubby Floppy Ear Plush Dog with Rattle Baby Toy

$9.77$4.88

First Main Thoughtfulness Tan Bear Plush 8.5 Inch Stuffed Animal Thinking of You

First Main Thoughtfulness Tan Bear Plush 8.5 Inch Stuffed Animal Thinking of You

$11.66$5.83

First & Main Murdoch Tan Brown 15" Teddy Bear With Bow Soft Cuddly Plush

First & Main Murdoch Tan Brown 15" Teddy Bear With Bow Soft Cuddly Plush

$28.75$14.38

Bearington Lovie and Dovey Plush Stuffed Animal Hedgehogs Holding Heart, 5.5

Bearington Lovie and Dovey Plush Stuffed Animal Hedgehogs Holding Heart, 5.5

$25.80$12.90

First & Main Softness Teddy Bear Baby Rattle Plush Lovey Soft Toy 2166 Stuffed

First & Main Softness Teddy Bear Baby Rattle Plush Lovey Soft Toy 2166 Stuffed

$14.99$7.50

First & Main Mini Hang A Round Lion Plush.

First & Main Mini Hang A Round Lion Plush.

$15.99$8.00

NEW with Tag - Plush Stuffed 11" Gray Elephant (Slowpoke) by First & Main 1002F

NEW with Tag - Plush Stuffed 11" Gray Elephant (Slowpoke) by First & Main 1002F

$9.95$4.97

Baby by First & Main No. 2763 Jingles Pink Plush Giraffe Rattle Girl

Baby by First & Main No. 2763 Jingles Pink Plush Giraffe Rattle Girl

$9.97$4.99

New First & Main Plush Blue Bear 12” TENDER TEDDY Heart Kelli Loons Tags

New First & Main Plush Blue Bear 12” TENDER TEDDY Heart Kelli Loons Tags

$11.99$6.00

First and Main Lankydoodle Plush Giraffe 15"

First and Main Lankydoodle Plush Giraffe 15"

$5.99$3.00

First And Main Plush Under The Sea Otter 10” Stuffed Animal No. 7883

First And Main Plush Under The Sea Otter 10” Stuffed Animal No. 7883

$9.99$5.00

First & Main Valentino Jr 9” Gorilla Realistic Black Furry Plush Stuffed Rose

First & Main Valentino Jr 9” Gorilla Realistic Black Furry Plush Stuffed Rose

$14.08$7.04

First & Main Teddy Bear Skidmore T. Bearsnickle Xs8015 Christmas Sweater 13 Inch

First & Main Teddy Bear Skidmore T. Bearsnickle Xs8015 Christmas Sweater 13 Inch

$6.93$3.46

First & Main Tillie Twinkletoes Ballerina Teddy Bear Toy Cream 12 Inch 2024

First & Main Tillie Twinkletoes Ballerina Teddy Bear Toy Cream 12 Inch 2024

$13.29$6.64

First & Main GOLDEN RETRIEVER Puppy Dog Boomer Plush Stuffed Toy 9 Inch

First & Main GOLDEN RETRIEVER Puppy Dog Boomer Plush Stuffed Toy 9 Inch

$6.93$3.46

NWT VERY RARE 90’s First & Main COMPLETE Set Of 6 RAINBOW BEARS Ages 3+

NWT VERY RARE 90’s First & Main COMPLETE Set Of 6 RAINBOW BEARS Ages 3+

$45.00$22.50

First And Main Thoughtfulness “Just For You” Teddy Bear Holding Flowers

First And Main Thoughtfulness “Just For You” Teddy Bear Holding Flowers

$9.00$4.50

First & Main White Teddy Bear Plush With Bow 10" Stuffed Animal #784 Dena

First & Main White Teddy Bear Plush With Bow 10" Stuffed Animal #784 Dena

$15.98$7.99

NWT First & Main Fanta ClipSeas Flamingo Pink Plush 5" Soft Key Chain Bag Charm

NWT First & Main Fanta ClipSeas Flamingo Pink Plush 5" Soft Key Chain Bag Charm

$6.99$3.50

First and Main White Bear Motivation I Believe in You Plush Stuffed Animal 5"

First and Main White Bear Motivation I Believe in You Plush Stuffed Animal 5"

$8.50$4.25

HTF 2 First & Main Menagerie FRAC & Fric Plush Teddy Bear Jointed & Hangtag EUC

HTF 2 First & Main Menagerie FRAC & Fric Plush Teddy Bear Jointed & Hangtag EUC

$12.99$6.50

Bearington Swings The Monkey Plush, 15 Inch Monkey Stuffed Animal

Bearington Swings The Monkey Plush, 15 Inch Monkey Stuffed Animal

$35.37$17.68

Stuffed Teddy Bear Dolls with Heart Cute Animal Plush Toy for Bear with heart

Stuffed Teddy Bear Dolls with Heart Cute Animal Plush Toy for Bear with heart

$21.99$10.99

First & Main Bando Halloween Pumpkin Plush Toy NWT

First & Main Bando Halloween Pumpkin Plush Toy NWT

$5.00$2.50

Big Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Giant Teddy Bear Plush with Ribbon Bow Red

Big Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Giant Teddy Bear Plush with Ribbon Bow Red

$46.77$23.39

First & Main Monkey Cutesys 2010 Soft Brown Monkey W/Tail Embroidered Plush

First & Main Monkey Cutesys 2010 Soft Brown Monkey W/Tail Embroidered Plush

$4.99$2.50

First & Main Bear Plush Cat Dress Black Zsa Zsa Halloween 10.5”

First & Main Bear Plush Cat Dress Black Zsa Zsa Halloween 10.5”

$13.99$7.00

First & Main Black Dimple Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Plush

First & Main Black Dimple Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Plush

$20.00$10.00

First & Main 12" Fritz the Striped Cat Plush with BellyButton

First & Main 12" Fritz the Striped Cat Plush with BellyButton

$17.99$8.99

Bearington Lovie and Dovey Plush Stuffed Animal Hedgehogs Holding Heart, 5.5

Bearington Lovie and Dovey Plush Stuffed Animal Hedgehogs Holding Heart, 5.5

$25.80$12.90

First & Main Tender Teddy Brown & White Bear w/ Patchwork Heart Lot Of Two Bears

First & Main Tender Teddy Brown & White Bear w/ Patchwork Heart Lot Of Two Bears

$17.39$8.70

First & Main Henderson Teddy Bear Tan Brown Plush 12" Corduroy Paws Holiday

First & Main Henderson Teddy Bear Tan Brown Plush 12" Corduroy Paws Holiday

$20.00$10.00

First And Main Michaels St. Jude's Brown Teddy Bear Plush/Stuffed Animal

First And Main Michaels St. Jude's Brown Teddy Bear Plush/Stuffed Animal

$16.99$8.49

First & Main White Teddy Bear Plush Super Soft Stuffed Animal 10" *Read Details*

First & Main White Teddy Bear Plush Super Soft Stuffed Animal 10" *Read Details*

$13.58$6.79

Snuggly Coco Bear Stuffed Animal - Comforting Companion - Imaginative Play -

Snuggly Coco Bear Stuffed Animal - Comforting Companion - Imaginative Play -

$24.93$12.46

DOJOZ Crystal Teddy Bear Valentines Day Sweet Gifts Figurine Red Heart Gold

DOJOZ Crystal Teddy Bear Valentines Day Sweet Gifts Figurine Red Heart Gold

$131.62$65.81

First & Main Plush Lot: 2 Santa Bears with Festive Hats, & Brown Guardian Angel

First & Main Plush Lot: 2 Santa Bears with Festive Hats, & Brown Guardian Angel

$19.99$9.99