banner-image
banner-image
banner-image
banner-image
18 inch Tanta Kringle Santa Claus Comin Coming to Town Rare Movie Promo Plush

18 inch Tanta Kringle Santa Claus Comin Coming to Town Rare Movie Promo Plush

$159.97$79.98

Stuffins Dachshund Puppy Realistic Dog Stuffed Bean Bag Animal VTG 1997 Toy Gift

Stuffins Dachshund Puppy Realistic Dog Stuffed Bean Bag Animal VTG 1997 Toy Gift

$23.11$11.55

Vintage Stuffins Nylon Puffalump Stuffed 8" Green Pink Wings Spikes Dragon Blue

Vintage Stuffins Nylon Puffalump Stuffed 8" Green Pink Wings Spikes Dragon Blue

$24.70$12.35

WIMPY Popeye CVS Stuffins Plush Toy 1999 - New witth Tags

WIMPY Popeye CVS Stuffins Plush Toy 1999 - New witth Tags

$16.80$8.40

Vtg 80’s Old Lumpy's Gang 16” Stuffins Neon Nylon Korea

Vtg 80’s Old Lumpy's Gang 16” Stuffins Neon Nylon Korea

$14.99$7.50

Stuffins Rudolph Island Of Misfit Toys BUMBLE ABOMINABLE SNOWMAN 7" Plush

Stuffins Rudolph Island Of Misfit Toys BUMBLE ABOMINABLE SNOWMAN 7" Plush

$11.99$6.00

NWT Vintage Dalmation RARE-12” 1998 CVS Stuffins Toys Plush Christmas w/ Hat

NWT Vintage Dalmation RARE-12” 1998 CVS Stuffins Toys Plush Christmas w/ Hat

$24.99$12.49

Disney Doc Stuffins Whiskers Pink Cat Kitten Stuffed Animal Plush Toy

Disney Doc Stuffins Whiskers Pink Cat Kitten Stuffed Animal Plush Toy

$14.79$7.39

Vintage Labrador Retriever Stuffins Stuffed Animal Black License No K-9 Plush

Vintage Labrador Retriever Stuffins Stuffed Animal Black License No K-9 Plush

$24.97$12.48

Stuffins Bullwinkle J Moose Plush Stuffed Animal 9 Inch 1999 Wossamotta U Banner

Stuffins Bullwinkle J Moose Plush Stuffed Animal 9 Inch 1999 Wossamotta U Banner

$15.98$7.99

Mr. Stuffins #3B (2009) Boom! Comics

Mr. Stuffins #3B (2009) Boom! Comics

$2.12$1.06

CVS 99 Stuffins Island of Misfit Toys Rudolph Red nose Plush Tags 8"

CVS 99 Stuffins Island of Misfit Toys Rudolph Red nose Plush Tags 8"

$24.99$12.49

Vintage Stuffins Rudolph Misfit Elf Hermey the Dentist Animated Talks Plush 7"

Vintage Stuffins Rudolph Misfit Elf Hermey the Dentist Animated Talks Plush 7"

$12.99$6.50

Stuffins CVS Misfit Cowboy Island of Toys Plush Ostrich Christmas 1999 w/Tag

Stuffins CVS Misfit Cowboy Island of Toys Plush Ostrich Christmas 1999 w/Tag

$24.60$12.30

NWT 14" Big Purple Stuffins 2000 Rainbow Ears Elephant Stuffed Animal Plush Toy

NWT 14" Big Purple Stuffins 2000 Rainbow Ears Elephant Stuffed Animal Plush Toy

$54.99$27.50

LOT OF 4 1999 STUFFINS UNIVERSAL HUNCHBACK OF NOTRE DAMN PLUSHIE

LOT OF 4 1999 STUFFINS UNIVERSAL HUNCHBACK OF NOTRE DAMN PLUSHIE

$26.00$13.00

Stuffins CVS 1999 Lt’d Edition Plush Olive Oyl 9" Collectible Popeye Character

Stuffins CVS 1999 Lt’d Edition Plush Olive Oyl 9" Collectible Popeye Character

$19.99$9.99

Universal Studios FAMOUS MONSTERS STUFFINS Plush Doll Heads Lot 1999 CVS RARE

Universal Studios FAMOUS MONSTERS STUFFINS Plush Doll Heads Lot 1999 CVS RARE

$34.95$17.48

Stuffins Universal Studios Monster Phantom Of The Opera Plush Doll 10" w 1999

Stuffins Universal Studios Monster Phantom Of The Opera Plush Doll 10" w 1999

$12.99$6.50

Island Of Misfit Toys CVS 1999 Rudolph Red Nosed Reindeer Cowboy Ostrich Plush

Island Of Misfit Toys CVS 1999 Rudolph Red Nosed Reindeer Cowboy Ostrich Plush

$34.99$17.50

Boss Elf 9" Plush Rudolph Island Of The Misfit Toys CVS 1999 Stuffins VTG

Boss Elf 9" Plush Rudolph Island Of The Misfit Toys CVS 1999 Stuffins VTG

$10.00$5.00

Stuffins Rudolph Island Of Misfit Toys Abominable Snowman Bumble 8” 1998 Plush

Stuffins Rudolph Island Of Misfit Toys Abominable Snowman Bumble 8” 1998 Plush

$19.99$9.99

Vintage Island of Misfit Toys Stuffins 9" Santa Claus stuffed bean bag plush

Vintage Island of Misfit Toys Stuffins 9" Santa Claus stuffed bean bag plush

$19.34$9.67

Rocky Squirrel Plush Ltd. Edition 1999 Stuffins Inc. RARE Large 20” CVS

Rocky Squirrel Plush Ltd. Edition 1999 Stuffins Inc. RARE Large 20” CVS

$14.00$7.00

Vtg 1999 CVS Stuffins Rudolph Misfit Toys Karen Girl Christmas Beanie Plush

Vtg 1999 CVS Stuffins Rudolph Misfit Toys Karen Girl Christmas Beanie Plush

$12.87$6.43

Vintage STUFFINS Stegosaurus Dinosaur Stuffed Plush Toy Neon Squeeze-Roar

Vintage STUFFINS Stegosaurus Dinosaur Stuffed Plush Toy Neon Squeeze-Roar

$19.99$9.99

Rudolph Island of Misfit Stuffins Plush Boss Elf & Herbie the Elf Christmas 1999

Rudolph Island of Misfit Stuffins Plush Boss Elf & Herbie the Elf Christmas 1999

$12.60$6.30

Snidely Whiplash Rocky & Bullwinkle Stuffins Plush CVS 1999 Limited Edition

Snidely Whiplash Rocky & Bullwinkle Stuffins Plush CVS 1999 Limited Edition

$16.10$8.05

Vintage Christmas Large Stuffins Santa Claus Holiday Plush Stuffed Toy 1993 16"

Vintage Christmas Large Stuffins Santa Claus Holiday Plush Stuffed Toy 1993 16"

$35.75$17.88

VINTAGE Santa Claus & Elf Nylon Parachute Plush Stuffins Stuffed Christmas Bell

VINTAGE Santa Claus & Elf Nylon Parachute Plush Stuffins Stuffed Christmas Bell

$12.50$6.25

Bride Of Frankenstein 9" Plush Universal Studios Monsters Stuffins 1999

Bride Of Frankenstein 9" Plush Universal Studios Monsters Stuffins 1999

$7.99$4.00

Frosty The Snowman Traffic Cop Stuffed Plush Doll Rare W/Tags Large 13” Stuffins

Frosty The Snowman Traffic Cop Stuffed Plush Doll Rare W/Tags Large 13” Stuffins

$35.16$17.58

Universal Monsters The Mummy Plush 9" 1999 Stuffins

Universal Monsters The Mummy Plush 9" 1999 Stuffins

$14.99$7.50

RUDOLPH THE RED NOSE REINDEER ISLAND OF MISFIT TOYS 1998 CVS / COMET

RUDOLPH THE RED NOSE REINDEER ISLAND OF MISFIT TOYS 1998 CVS / COMET

$24.95$12.47

Vintage Stuffins Dinosaur PTERODACTYL plush Neon Yellow Green nylon Squeaker 90s

Vintage Stuffins Dinosaur PTERODACTYL plush Neon Yellow Green nylon Squeaker 90s

$8.99$4.50

CVS 1999 LARGE Stuffins Hermie Elf Dentist Plush Island Misfit Toys Rudolph RARE

CVS 1999 LARGE Stuffins Hermie Elf Dentist Plush Island Misfit Toys Rudolph RARE

$89.00$44.50

Rudolph Misfit Toys Santa Claus Plush Bean Bag Stuffed Vintage 1999 Stuffins Toy

Rudolph Misfit Toys Santa Claus Plush Bean Bag Stuffed Vintage 1999 Stuffins Toy

$17.00$8.50

Vintage 1993 Christmas 5" Stuffins Plush Ornaments Bear

Vintage 1993 Christmas 5" Stuffins Plush Ornaments Bear

$2.50$1.25

Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer Island Misfit Toys Plush Sings The Theme Song 6”

Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer Island Misfit Toys Plush Sings The Theme Song 6”

$24.90$12.45

Adventures Of Rocky & Bullwinkle Collectible Keychain Set Vintage 1999 Stuffins

Adventures Of Rocky & Bullwinkle Collectible Keychain Set Vintage 1999 Stuffins

$33.96$16.98

Vintage Green Bay Packers Cheese Head NFL Team Heroes Plush Stuffins Pillow 1997

Vintage Green Bay Packers Cheese Head NFL Team Heroes Plush Stuffins Pillow 1997

$30.00$15.00

Rudolph Island Of Misfit Toys Clarice CVS Stuffins 7" Plush VTG 1998 NWT & Protr

Rudolph Island Of Misfit Toys Clarice CVS Stuffins 7" Plush VTG 1998 NWT & Protr

$35.00$17.50

Stuffins Fairy Tail Friends Mother Goose Plush Toy

Stuffins Fairy Tail Friends Mother Goose Plush Toy

$19.99$9.99

Vtg Stuffins CVS 7” Herbie Tall Elf Santa Claus Rudolph Plush Lot Tags

Vtg Stuffins CVS 7” Herbie Tall Elf Santa Claus Rudolph Plush Lot Tags

$20.99$10.49

Stuffins Rocky & Bullwinkle & Friends Boris Badenov Plush 1999 VTG CVS W/ Tag

Stuffins Rocky & Bullwinkle & Friends Boris Badenov Plush 1999 VTG CVS W/ Tag

$5.39$2.69

Stuffins BOSS ELF beanbag plush 1999 Rudolph Red Nosed Reindeer Lot #6143

Stuffins BOSS ELF beanbag plush 1999 Rudolph Red Nosed Reindeer Lot #6143

$14.00$7.00

Rudolph Island Of Misfit Toys Abominable CVS Stuffins 10" Plush VTG 1999 NWT

Rudolph Island Of Misfit Toys Abominable CVS Stuffins 10" Plush VTG 1999 NWT

$34.99$17.50

9 Stuffins Misfit Toys - USED

9 Stuffins Misfit Toys - USED

$100.00$50.00

Rudolph Stuffins CVS Abominable Snowman Plush Island Of Misfit Toys 8'' Yeti

Rudolph Stuffins CVS Abominable Snowman Plush Island Of Misfit Toys 8'' Yeti

$22.00$11.00

Rudolph Misfit Train Plush 6" Choo Choo with Square Wheels CVS Stuffins 1998

Rudolph Misfit Train Plush 6" Choo Choo with Square Wheels CVS Stuffins 1998

$19.98$9.99

Stuffins Vintage 1990 Purple Pink Nylon 8" Gorilla Ape Squeaking Plush (P22)

Stuffins Vintage 1990 Purple Pink Nylon 8" Gorilla Ape Squeaking Plush (P22)

$22.49$11.24

RARE CHRISTMAS PLUSH DOLL FIGURE HERMEY HERMIE DENTIST BOOK STUFFINS DENTIST TOY

RARE CHRISTMAS PLUSH DOLL FIGURE HERMEY HERMIE DENTIST BOOK STUFFINS DENTIST TOY

$14.00$7.00

VintageHalloween Stuffins Plush Skeleton 26" Top Hat Dracula 22” 1995

VintageHalloween Stuffins Plush Skeleton 26" Top Hat Dracula 22” 1995

$29.00$14.50

Stuffins Lumpys Bean Bag Gang Pink Groovey Gator Plush w/ tags 9"

Stuffins Lumpys Bean Bag Gang Pink Groovey Gator Plush w/ tags 9"

$10.00$5.00

Very rare Stuffins cat plush Yellow Green eyes kitty scaredy Lumpys Gang Beanie

Very rare Stuffins cat plush Yellow Green eyes kitty scaredy Lumpys Gang Beanie

$51.00$25.50

1999 Stuffins Rudolph and The Island of Misfit Toys Coach Comet NWT

1999 Stuffins Rudolph and The Island of Misfit Toys Coach Comet NWT

$16.00$8.00

Stuffins Rocky And Bullwinkle And Friends Mr. Peabody With Pipe Plush 1999

Stuffins Rocky And Bullwinkle And Friends Mr. Peabody With Pipe Plush 1999

$11.99$6.00

Rudolph Island Of Misfit Toys Sam The Snowman Stuffins CVS Plush Tags

Rudolph Island Of Misfit Toys Sam The Snowman Stuffins CVS Plush Tags

$15.99$8.00

Rare Vtg Rubber Face Pumpkin Head Plush 33" Halloween Decoration Stuffins Wierd

Rare Vtg Rubber Face Pumpkin Head Plush 33" Halloween Decoration Stuffins Wierd

$40.00$20.00

Stuffins Rocky and Bullwinkle & Friends Plush Most With Tags Lot Of 11 Preowned

Stuffins Rocky and Bullwinkle & Friends Plush Most With Tags Lot Of 11 Preowned

$49.99$25.00

2 Stuffins Monster 1999 Vtg Plush Dolls Wolf man & Dracula

2 Stuffins Monster 1999 Vtg Plush Dolls Wolf man & Dracula

$19.99$9.99

Vintage Stuffins Tie-dye Gray Elephant Kids Toy Stuffed Animal 14" Plush

Vintage Stuffins Tie-dye Gray Elephant Kids Toy Stuffed Animal 14" Plush

$12.60$6.30

1999 CVS Rudolph red nosed reindeer Island Misfit Toys 12” Stuffins Hermey Elf

1999 CVS Rudolph red nosed reindeer Island Misfit Toys 12” Stuffins Hermey Elf

$12.00$6.00

Vintage Sam the Snowman Plush Toys Rudolph CVS Stuffins Stuffed Plush Misfit Toy

Vintage Sam the Snowman Plush Toys Rudolph CVS Stuffins Stuffed Plush Misfit Toy

$14.39$7.20

Dallas Cowboys Mascot Rowdy 2 Plush 1996 Stuffins 13” NFL & 1979 Cheer Van

Dallas Cowboys Mascot Rowdy 2 Plush 1996 Stuffins 13” NFL & 1979 Cheer Van

$29.99$14.99

Stuffins Vintage Halloween Jack O Lantern Pumpkin Colorful Plush - 1993

Stuffins Vintage Halloween Jack O Lantern Pumpkin Colorful Plush - 1993

$24.99$12.49

Stuffins & Floppy Friends Plush Boston Terrier Puppy Dogs Stuffed Animals Vtg

Stuffins & Floppy Friends Plush Boston Terrier Puppy Dogs Stuffed Animals Vtg

$18.00$9.00

Christmas Plush Snowman Snowball Lil Softies White Reindeer Dancer Stuffins 6”

Christmas Plush Snowman Snowball Lil Softies White Reindeer Dancer Stuffins 6”

$9.95$4.97

Vintage Stuffins Rudolph Island of Misfit Toys , YUKON CORNELIUS Tags Keychain

Vintage Stuffins Rudolph Island of Misfit Toys , YUKON CORNELIUS Tags Keychain

$17.95$8.97

1999 RUDOLPH SAM THE SNOWMAN PLUSH STUFFINS ISLAND MISFIT TOYS CVS TAG LIMITED

1999 RUDOLPH SAM THE SNOWMAN PLUSH STUFFINS ISLAND MISFIT TOYS CVS TAG LIMITED

$10.00$5.00

CVS The Island of Misfit Toys - Misfit Water Pistol - 1999 - 9"

CVS The Island of Misfit Toys - Misfit Water Pistol - 1999 - 9"

$23.09$11.54

Vintage Lion Plush King and Cub With Gold Crowns Stuffins Stuffed Animal w/Tag

Vintage Lion Plush King and Cub With Gold Crowns Stuffins Stuffed Animal w/Tag

$18.39$9.20

Sam the Snowman Island of Misfit Toys Rudolph CVS Stuffins 1998 7" Stuffed Plush

Sam the Snowman Island of Misfit Toys Rudolph CVS Stuffins 1998 7" Stuffed Plush

$15.95$7.97

Stuffins Yukon Cornelius CVS

Stuffins Yukon Cornelius CVS

$10.00$5.00

Vintage Stuffins 1996 Halloween Rare 22" Dracula Vampire Nylon Plush Doll

Vintage Stuffins 1996 Halloween Rare 22" Dracula Vampire Nylon Plush Doll

$24.99$12.49

ROCKY & BULLWINKLE FRIENDS 6" HORSE STUFFINS PLUSH CVS EUC

ROCKY & BULLWINKLE FRIENDS 6" HORSE STUFFINS PLUSH CVS EUC

$10.20$5.10

CVS STUFFINS BUMBLES ABOMINABLE SNOWMAN RUDOLPH ISLAND OF MISFIT TOYS PLUSH 1999

CVS STUFFINS BUMBLES ABOMINABLE SNOWMAN RUDOLPH ISLAND OF MISFIT TOYS PLUSH 1999

$12.50$6.25

NWT 1999 CVS Plush DRACULA Stuffins Universal Studios Monsters Halloween Vintage

NWT 1999 CVS Plush DRACULA Stuffins Universal Studios Monsters Halloween Vintage

$14.99$7.50

Vintage 1998 Stuffins Rudolph Island of Misfit Toys - Abominable Snowman W/ Tag

Vintage 1998 Stuffins Rudolph Island of Misfit Toys - Abominable Snowman W/ Tag

$20.00$10.00

Rudolph The Red Nosed Reindeer CVS - Limited Edition 50th Anniversary Stuffins

Rudolph The Red Nosed Reindeer CVS - Limited Edition 50th Anniversary Stuffins

$11.50$5.75

Stuffins Blue Bear Bee Sweet 19" Plush Stuffed Animal

Stuffins Blue Bear Bee Sweet 19" Plush Stuffed Animal

$42.99$21.50

Stuffins Universal Monsters HUNCHBACK OF NOTRE DAME 6" Plush Toy from CVS

Stuffins Universal Monsters HUNCHBACK OF NOTRE DAME 6" Plush Toy from CVS

$4.00$2.00

VTG 1998 Island of Misfit Toys Hermey The Dentist Elf 8"T Plush Ornament Rudolph

VTG 1998 Island of Misfit Toys Hermey The Dentist Elf 8"T Plush Ornament Rudolph

$7.00$3.50

Stuffins CVS 2000 Limited Edition Plush Brutus 8" Collectible w/Tags

Stuffins CVS 2000 Limited Edition Plush Brutus 8" Collectible w/Tags

$15.99$8.00

Vintage Universal Monsters Stuffins Bride of Frankenstein 9” See Details

Vintage Universal Monsters Stuffins Bride of Frankenstein 9” See Details

$14.39$7.20

CVS Stuffins Limited Edition "Karen" Frosty The Snowman 1999 Plush Ornament New

CVS Stuffins Limited Edition "Karen" Frosty The Snowman 1999 Plush Ornament New

$17.99$8.99

Stuffins Rocky and Bullwinkle & Friends CVS Boris Badenov 8" Plush 2000

Stuffins Rocky and Bullwinkle & Friends CVS Boris Badenov 8" Plush 2000

$9.79$4.89

CVS Stuffins 8" Plush KAREN Doll FROSTY THE SNOWMAN Stuffed Toy 1999

CVS Stuffins 8" Plush KAREN Doll FROSTY THE SNOWMAN Stuffed Toy 1999

$18.00$9.00

Frosty the Snowman Plush 8" Stuffins CVS 1999 with Broom Pipe Hat

Frosty the Snowman Plush 8" Stuffins CVS 1999 with Broom Pipe Hat

$10.00$5.00

Rudolph Island of Misfit Toys Hermie Dentist 1998 CVS Plush 7” Stuffins Vintage

Rudolph Island of Misfit Toys Hermie Dentist 1998 CVS Plush 7” Stuffins Vintage

$9.99$5.00

Vintage 1998 Lisa Frank LOLLIPOP White Plush Horse JUMBO 33" Original

Vintage 1998 Lisa Frank LOLLIPOP White Plush Horse JUMBO 33" Original

$79.98$39.99

Vintage 1993 Christmas 5" Stuffins Plush Ornaments Mouse Nylon Puffalump Style

Vintage 1993 Christmas 5" Stuffins Plush Ornaments Mouse Nylon Puffalump Style

$5.25$2.63

CVS Stuffins Frosty The Snowman Karen Plush Doll Christmas Ornament Vtg

CVS Stuffins Frosty The Snowman Karen Plush Doll Christmas Ornament Vtg

$8.00$4.00

Used Stuffins Plush Fearless Leader & Snidely Whiplash *Rocky & Bullwinkle* READ

Used Stuffins Plush Fearless Leader & Snidely Whiplash *Rocky & Bullwinkle* READ

$12.39$6.20

MC STUFFINS HALLIE HIPPO DISNEY 2” ACTION FIGURE TOY (PRE-OWNED)

MC STUFFINS HALLIE HIPPO DISNEY 2” ACTION FIGURE TOY (PRE-OWNED)

$5.16$2.58

1999 Stuffins CVS Universal Studios Monster 8 Inch HUNCHBACK Plush Beanie EUC

1999 Stuffins CVS Universal Studios Monster 8 Inch HUNCHBACK Plush Beanie EUC

$14.99$7.50

VTG 1998 CVS Stuffins 12" Herbie Hermie Elf Island of Misfit Toys w/Tags TubS

VTG 1998 CVS Stuffins 12" Herbie Hermie Elf Island of Misfit Toys w/Tags TubS

$34.99$17.50

Lisa Frank Boobsidoodle Stuffins Bunny Plush

Lisa Frank Boobsidoodle Stuffins Bunny Plush

$45.00$22.50

Rocky and Bullwinkle and Friends Snidley Whiplash 9" Plush Toy 1999 CVS Stuffins

Rocky and Bullwinkle and Friends Snidley Whiplash 9" Plush Toy 1999 CVS Stuffins

$10.00$5.00

Vtg Boyds Bears Brown Teddy Bear In Blue Stocking Hat 8” Jingle S Stuffins Plush

Vtg Boyds Bears Brown Teddy Bear In Blue Stocking Hat 8” Jingle S Stuffins Plush

$10.49$5.25